Nashville s5 ep 5

Not for the first time this season, the best – most interesting, most thought-provoking, sweetest – storyline goes to Older Girl, so I don’t know what the hell’s going on there. I’m even going to refer to her as Maddie this week. Call it a promotion. She’s totally into street musician Clay, who seems to be what parents like me would call a “nice boy”. However, Clay decorously refuses even to make out with her, which at first he claims is because she’s underage, but which will turn out also to be connected to her unacknowledged #privilege, and him being bipolar. Which is, y’know, quite a lot with which to deal.

After he’s been beaten up by a couple of racist douches, Clay testily wonders whether Maddie wants him just to wander up to her parents’ front door all, hey there, I’m the broke, older, bipolar African American dude who’s dating your daughter? “Yes”, Maddie replies, “that’s exactly what I want. Because you’re brilliant, and I care so much about you”. The show even gives us a lovely scene with Maddie and Juliette – who tends to be at her best in these situations – as Maddie asks for advice on what to do. Meh, says Juliette, “screwed-up men are sexy. Don’t ask me why. Until they’re not”. (I have no comment to make.) But then Clay does what Maddie hoped he would: he turns up at her house and introduces himself to her parents. I can’t imagine that Rayna and Deacon will be overjoyed once they realise that Clay is a homeless street musician, but for now it’s all quite touching.

I’m not sure quite to make of the Gunnar and Scarlett storyline this week, which may be a good thing. They’re filming a video with Zach’s man, Mr Big Shot Director, who has a Big Shot Concept that Scarlett just isn’t buying into; and, on the evidence of what we see, she probably has a point. This isn’t good enough for Mr BSD, though, who treats her appallingly – maybe in the hope of dragging out of her the performance he thinks her capable of, but he dresses it up with bullshit about how Scarlett needs to “embrace (her) sexuality on (her) terms”, which no she doesn’t, and shut up. At the end of filming, he justifies his behaviour by telling her to watch the video, which we haven’t yet seen; and, I must admit, I am actually keen to see it.

My suspicion, mind you, is that this is just being used as another method of driving a wedge between Gunnar and Scarlett; a suspicion which is heightened by the way in which their past relationship is caricatured. No, folks, Gunnar wasn’t screwing around with half of Nashville (or whatever it was); he and Scarlett had split up and he was dating other women, as he was entitled to do, and if Scarlett didn’t want to see him with other women she shouldn’t have broken up with him. We’re not even in we-were-on-a-break territory here, and turning this into Gunnar’s fault – and something for which he and only he needs to be forgiven? – assumes that we’ve forgotten about Dr Yoko, for one.

Meantime, Randall is sacked for being a creep, but not a stalker. The real stalker turns up at Highway 65 later. I don’t think we’ve seen him before. Presumably we’ll see more of him next week. I can’t wait. I thought this was an excellent episode.


2 thoughts on “Nashville s5 ep 5

  1. CJ Cregg June 6, 2017 / 1:37 pm

    Could be wrong but I thought we had seen the real stalker before – is he not the guy who stopped Rayna in the street a few eps ago and wanted a photo? While Bucky was taking it, the guy was totes creepy and starting asking if Maddie was at home or something and it (justifiably) freaked Rayna out.

    I had the same thought as you re how they’re completely re-writing history re Gunnar. I kept shouting things like “but Scarlett was going out with that other guy!”, and “Eh? There’s nothing to forgive him for” etc at the screen. That would have been bad enough but I didn’t get the point of the video director storyline either. Are we supposed to think Scarlett *should* let go of her inhibitions? Or shouldn’t? I have no idea. I found the whole thing really uncomfortable. And it didn’t seem to go with the song which seemed (from the little we heard of it) more on the sweeter side of love songs than the dark one if you know what I mean. Maybe the album version is different…

    Still don’t care about Maddie/Older Girl and really not keen on her slowly moving into female lead position – she is getting a LOT of screen time. Her scene with Juliette was good though – I agree that’s when Juliette’s at her best.

    • Jed Bartlet June 6, 2017 / 8:38 pm

      You could be right about the stalker.

      As for Scarlett and the director: I quite liked how unsettling it was, and how it wasn’t immediately evident where our sympathies were supposed to lie. I mean, dude’s a jerk, but until we see the video we don’t know how much slack to cut him. The Gunnar stuff was annoying, though.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s