Doctor Who s35 ep 8

Part two of The Zygon Invasion gives us The Zygon Inversion: Clara, Osgood and the Doctor may be down, but they’re not out yet. Bonnie must be stopped, but the question is whether that can be done without actually facilitating the genocide that Bonnie wants – be it of humans, Zygons or both.

For all the stakes are astronomical, this is a calmer, less manic episode, and a much more enjoyable, poignant one for it, with the show wearing its heart infinitely more clearly on its sleeve than last week’s. I love big themes in my genre shows, but Steven Moffat’s Doctor Who works best for me when it’s exploring those big themes via a smaller group of characters and their feelings in a more contained way, as it did this week, rather than going all big-budget bombastic like last week’s attempts at the Whovian version of Independence Day.

The political metaphor is still pretty blunt this week, mind you – “It’s a splinter group.” – but its message is far less murky, and, as I hoped last week, full of hope and inclusiveness, making clear that just because some people commit appalling crimes in the name of religious or racial hatred, doesn’t mean everyone of that same religion or race endorses them, and it certainly doesn’t mean you punish or persecute everyone of that same religion or race for them. It’s astonishing that, in the 21st century, that still has to be said, but the recent rise in hate crime and the increasingly mainstream nature of hate rhetoric suggests that it does, so the bewildered, blameless Zygon who said “I’m not part of your fight. I never wanted to fight anyone. I just wanted to live here. Why can’t I live here?” may only have had a few minutes’ screen time, but, as far as I’m concerned, he spoke for millions of us in the process.

Eloquence and hearts in the right place aside, though, this being a kids show, the resolution was a bit too easy. The Doctor’s speech about forgiveness and the real Truth and Consequences of war was a bravura scene for Peter Capaldi; a moving, valiant plea for diplomacy and peaceful resolution in a world desperately in need of both. But the defiantly hate-filled Bonnie accepting it so quickly seemed unlikely, and anyone, even the faithful Osgood trusting her to keep the peace even more so.

Then again, maybe it wasn’t as quick as I thought. The Doctor’s cryptic comments about time at the end of the episode suggest that Clara was gone a lot longer than we thought, after all. That’s a question for later episodes, though. As far as this one’s concerned, I was apprehensive last week about whether it would stick the landing. For the most part, I think it did.

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “Doctor Who s35 ep 8

  1. e November 9, 2015 / 2:38 am

    I don’t understand why you’re still watching this drek when there’s the delightful Jekyll and Hottie to watch instead. Same target audience. Same level of scare behind the sofa. But far more fun to me in the 3 eps so far.

    • CJ Cregg November 9, 2015 / 11:28 pm

      Sorry e, but the Jekyll & Hyde clips I’ve seen look awful. I prefer my “inner demon” stories to involve actual vampires, as you know 😉

  2. Tim November 9, 2015 / 2:25 pm

    This was very nearly a proper Who classic for me, let down by a somewhat flabby first part. Capaldi is at his best here, and I liked that this story – despite some on-the-nose allusions to the real world – stayed firmly camped in shades of grey rather than simplifying an issue that is anything but simple.

    • CJ Cregg November 9, 2015 / 11:29 pm

      Capaldi was fantastic, I agree, Tim. Not everyone could have carried off the big speech at the end but he did so brilliantly.

  3. Capt. Harold Dobey November 14, 2015 / 10:09 pm

    If this had been on a week later the message is so blunt that it would have been pulled like that Star Trek episode they didn’t for show ages.

    I watched the two episodes together and the first made better sense and I enjoyed them both as a whole. As Tim says, it was nearly Who Classic.

    Memory wipes are a bit lazy though and I think we’d just have accepted a negotiation settlement first time round. It made sense.

    Probably only really an episode and a half here, but I suppose Classic Who would have filler in 4 or 6 episodes too. It’s fairly common on the BBC. There’s an episode of State Of Play where I thought they’d shown last week’s in error.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s