Jane the Virgin s1 ep 16

CJ was a big fan of Jane the Virgin straight out of the gate, but it took me a few weeks to get the point: I could see that it was nice and all, but I wasn’t sold on it, and anyway I thought that the character of Michael had been treated a little shoddily, if I’m being honest. But I was wrong. This is a truly great show: romantic without being cloying; preposterously plotted, yet with genuine emotion at its core; and very funny. It has strong female characters and (what seems to me like) a solid grasp of Hispanic American life, but without being didactic about any of it. Also, a telenovela which is (at least in part) about a telenovela is always going to be a little meta at least, but Jane the Virgin manages to be cleverly and amusingly knowing rather than smug about it. (Interestingly, judging from an exchange of texts I had with CJ recently, she seems to have gone off the show just as I’ve resolved to marry it and have its children.)

On top of all of that, the show has a great central performance by Gina Rodriguez as Jane, who feels like a person of real substance, sympathetic yet purposeful. Nor does it hurt that Rodriguez evinces a sort of sweet and well-scrubbed sexiness. The Latin Lover Narrator, of course, is just fabulous, and gets a reasonable proportion of the best lines. The use of onscreen text has got saltier and funnier every week. (In this episode, for example, the captions for the dog’s barks made me laugh out loud.) And the supporting cast is strong, in particular Jaime Camil as the outstandingly vain and egotistical telenovela star Rogelio De La Vega, who just lights the screen up every time he’s on it, even when playing a peach-clad intergalactic detective.

This episode might have been one of the best so far: Jane has writers’ block, a not-particularly-subtle metaphor for her relationship with Rafael, which is in trouble after she rejected his proposal of marriage. Rogelio is shadowing Michael as part of his research for playing the aforementioned peach-clad intergalactic detective (“I take my craft very seriously, which you can see by my use of the word ‘craft’”. Later on, in a fantasy sequence, they will dance a salsa. God, I love Rogelio.) Petra – the exceptional Yael Grobglas – has started to work more closely with Rafael. Jane unknowingly meets Michael’s ex-girlfriend at her writers’ workshop. And Xo is planning to move in with Rogelio, which has annoyed her mother (whose character is arguably the only weak link in the show, which is not in any way the fault of Ivonne Coll who plays the role).

I absolutely adore this show. If you’re not watching, give it a try.

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “Jane the Virgin s1 ep 16

  1. e August 8, 2015 / 1:17 am

    I think this would have been far better as a 10-13 ep show than a 22 ep one. And there’s something that happens in the last 5 minutes of the show that really annoyed me.

    Other than that, agree with everything.

  2. Jed Bartlet August 8, 2015 / 8:37 am

    Most shows would probably be better at 10-13 eps, I think. And capped at three seasons, like term limits for politicians.

    • e August 8, 2015 / 9:46 pm

      Person of Interest, which gets more spectacular by the season also suffers from the 22 ep drag. It becomes more and more noticeable over time as it transforms from an okay procedural to a top-of-the-line thriller

  3. CJ Cregg August 9, 2015 / 7:32 pm

    I don’t disagree with most of what you said in your post, Jed – the show is lovely, moving and often very funny; Jane, Rogelio and the Narrator are fantastic; and I do still like it a lot. But I’m currently a few weeks behind and bored with the Sin Rostro plot, not looking forward to whatever double-cross Rogelio’s writer and assistant are planning, and do not want to see any more of Petra than can absolutely be helped. Mid-season fatigue is setting in and it feels like the show’s going round in circles. E is right – this would have been much better as 10-13 eps. Hopefully, once I get over the hump of the middle eight, it’ll pick up pace and I’ll adore it again.

    I actually really like Alba, btw. Michael, however, sucks, and after a weird, portentous line from the narrator a couple of eps ago about him believing he and Jane would get back together till the day he died (or something) I just keep waiting for him to be killed….

  4. Jed Bartlet August 10, 2015 / 5:25 pm

    I must admit that I was wondering myself, about six or so episodes in, how the show could be sustained for a full season. But I’ve enjoyed the last three or four episodes more than anything else in the show so far. Even Petra becomes more nuanced and tolerable, perhaps even likeable.

    Yeah, that line about Michael was a bit of an anvil. I don’t think he sucks, though, and as I said I thought his character was treated poorly in the first half of the season. My problem character is Alba because I just don’t buy that sort of purse-lipped piety from someone in respect of a daughter in her 40s; or at least I don’t get why any of the other characters feel obliged to treat it remotely seriously. But there we go, and Ivonne Coll is doing her very best with it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s