Game of Thrones s2 ep7

“Walking back to wildling land, whoop-ah-oh-yeah…”

Does anyone know where poor Smoulders-in-the Snow actually thought he was going?  Sigh.  Every second scene, there he was, blushing, freezing, but always with the walking…to where, Jon?  What was the plan?   Did you think your boys’d let you keep her?

In between, other characters were killing, bickering, bonding, but Jon and Patsy Palmer Ygritte just kept right on walking.  Robb flirted,  Theon murdered, some stuff happened with Daeny that I don’t give a mutton stew about and will therefore completely ignore for the rest of this post, and yet the Snow Patrol were STILL walking. 

Poor Smoulders.  So pretty but so astonishingly dim.  And so easily flustered by a girl.  Their monarchist vs democrat (of sorts) clash of ideologies was cute, and while her “earthier” baiting of him got a bit embarrassing for me, let alone Mr Precious, it was, in fairness, reasonably funny at first.  But all that WALKING seemed to go on forever.

It seems churlish to complain, though, when it was just one of several strands of beautifully realised character development woven through the episode.  Because “A Man Without Honour” was very much an episode about character and the interplay between characters, rather than the action itself despite how shocking some of that action was: it’s not like I’ll forget Jamie’s cold-blooded killing of Ser Alton or what Theon did (I’ll come back to that in a minute) any time soon.   But each incident showed us every character’s true nature, shaped by power and honour or lack thereof – contrast Robb’s concern for all his wounded prisoners and Ser Alton with Tywin’s coldly efficient ruthlessness, and the madness of King Joffrey (out of sight this week, but never out of mind) whose own mother despairs of the monster power has shown him to be.  

I suppose it’s fitting though that the worst villain this time around was the character with the weakest nature as Theon, a man who had already passed the point of no return with the execution of Ser Rodrik , essentially lapped himself this week with something too horrific to even contemplate: My God.  I’m pretty sure Rickon and Bran are ok, but two other little boys are definitely not, so, frankly, the re-taking of Winterfell cannot come fast enough.

This was another talky episode, then, but so much of the talking was fantastic, it didn’t matter.  Cersei’s guilt-ridden confession to Tyrion and his awkward attempt to comfort her, Tywin and Arya’s verbal sparring, and of course Catelyn’s magnificent confrontation with the Kingslayer himself: all marvellous.  I could happily have sat through even more talking of that calibre.  But perhaps a little less of the walking.


2 thoughts on “Game of Thrones s2 ep7

  1. Tim May 15, 2012 / 12:52 am

    I prefer to think of Snow -in-the-snow as an homage to The West Wing’s walk-and-talk sequences, just a lot slower and a lot colder … 😉

    Very little happened in this episode in terms of moving the main thrust on – you know, that war thing – and yet at the same time so much did. In particular, the scenes between Arya and Tywin were magnificent. And in general the episode made me feel that little bit more sympathetic towards characters we are supposed to hate: Tywin, Jaime, Cersei, Joffrey. Okay, okay, nothing could ever make me feel sympathetic towards Joffrey.

    As for Theon: oh dear, oh dear, oh dear. The more he tries to prove himself as a man, the more he succeeds in achieving the exact opposite. Arya is more of a man than he will ever be.

  2. CJ Cregg May 15, 2012 / 9:25 pm

    Heh – snap, Tim. I was thinking of The West Wing, too.

    I agree with you on the sympathy for the Lannisters front – particularly for Tywin and Jamie who are both so charismatic that it’s easy to be slightly bewitched by them when they try to get you to see things their way. I can see why their men follow them so readily (their charisma and the threat of obliteration obviously!). But I did think Jaime even trying to suggest that he was more honourable than Ned was a bit of a stretch even if it was just to annoy Cat – no matter how many vows the man has taken, I doubt he was ever confused as to the innate dishonour in having an affair with his sister, murdering his cousin in cold blood and throwing a 10 year old out of a window to cover up his secrets.

    The one thing I do think he’s entitled to feel a bit aggrieved about though is that “Kingslayer” is always said with contempt – you’d think the Westerosi would have been grateful to get shot of the (previous) crazed and homicidal king, feudal monarchy or not!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s